Parashat Hashavua
Yeshivat Har Etzion

This parasha series is dedicated
Le-zekher Nishmat HaRabanit Chana bat HaRav Yehuda Zelig zt"l.

********************************************************

This parasha series is dedicated
in honor of Rabbi Menachem Leibtag and Rabbi Elchanan Samet.

********************************************************

PARASHAT VAYECHI

*********************************************************

Dedicated in memory of my grandmother, Szore bath Simen Leib (Weinberger),

whose yahrzeit is on the 18^th of Tevet. May her soul be among the Righteous in Gan Eden.  – from those who remember her.

*********************************************************

Dedicated in loving memory of
Shmuel Nachamu ben Shlomo Moshe HaKohen (whose yahrtzeit falls on 10 Tevet),

Chaya bat Yitzchak Dovid (whose yahrtzeit falls on 15 Tevet),

and Shimon ben Moshe (whose yahrtzeit falls on 16 Tevet).

*********************************************************

Mazal Tov to Jonny Bernstein on the occasion of the anniversary of his Bar-Mitzvah! All our love, the Family

*********************************************************

Yosef – From Exile to Redemption

Rabbanit Sharon Rimon

            Parashat Vayechi, at the end of Sefer Bereishit, concludes the stories of the patriarchs, preparing the reader for Sefer Shemot which introduces the story of the nation[1][1]; the story of exile and redemption.

The Death of Yaakov and the Death of Yosef

            Although the parasha gets its name from the opening word, "va-yechi" – denoting life – the parasha actually describes the death of two people: Yaakov and Yosef.

            The parasha begins with a description of Yaakov's preparations, knowing that he is about to die. He commands Yosef to bury him in Eretz Kena'an; he declares that Efrayim and Menasheh will have special status as sons deserving of an inheritance; he blesses all of his children, and commands all of them to bury him in Me'arat ha-makhpela. The text then describes his death, the mourning that follows, and the funeral procession.

            Following Yaakov's death there is a conversation between Yosef and his brothers, straightening out the affairs between them. The parasha then ends with Yosef's parting words to his brothers, and then his death.

            If we compare the two descriptions of death – that of Yaakov and that of Yosef – we find a considerable degree of similarity. Admittedly, the description in Yaakov's case is far more detailed, but the same central elements appear in both:

1.Dwelling in Egypt:

Yaakov: "And Yisrael dwelled in the land of Egypt" (47:27)

Yosef: "And Yosef dwelled in Egypt – he and his father's household" (50:22)

2.Noting of the length of life:

Yaakov: "And Yaakov's lifetime, the years of his life, were a hundred and forty-seven years" (47:25)

Yosef: "And Yosef lived a hundred and ten years" (50:22)

3.Mention of the redemption:

Yaakov: "And Yisrael said to Yosef: Behold, I am going to die, but God will be with you and restore you to the land of your forefathers" (48:21)

Yosef:[2][2] "And Yosef said to his brothers: I am going to die, but God will surely remember you and bring you up from this land to the land which He promised to Avraham, to Yitzchak, and to Yaakov" (50:24)

4.Command concerning burial in the land:

Yaakov: "Place your hand under my thigh, and act towards me with kindness and truth: do not bury me in Egypt.

Let me lie with my ancestors; you shall carry me from Egypt and bury me in their burial place.[3][3] And he said: Swear to me; and he swore to him" (47:29-31)

"Bury me with my ancestors at the cave which is in the field of Efron, the Hittite" (49:29-32)

Yosef: "And Yosef caused Bnei Yisrael to swear[4][4], saying… And you shall take up my bones from here" (50:25)

5.The death:

Yaakov: "And he gathered his legs to his bed, and he expired, and was gathered to his people" (49:33)

Yosef: "And Yosef died, aged a hundred and ten" (50:26)

6.Embalming:

Yaakov: "And the physicians embalmed Yisrael" (50:2)

Yosef: "And they embalmed him" (50:26)

7.Burial:

Yaakov: "And Yosef went up to bury his father" (50:7)

"And his sons carried him to the land of Kena'an, and they buried him in the cave of the field of Makhpela" (50:13)

Yosef: "And placed him in a casket in Egypt" (50:26)

Both Yaakov and Yosef know that there will be a redemption from Egypt, and both command their descendants to bury them in Eretz Kena'an. However, there are two important differences between them:

a. Yaakov does not tell all of his sons that there will be a redemption; he tells only Yosef. Yosef, on the other hand, tells all of his brothers.

b.Yaakov's body is brought to Eretz Kena'an for burial, while Yosef's body remains, for the meantime, in a casket in Egypt.

Why is Yosef's body left, for the meantime, in Egypt? Why does he not command his sons to bury him right away, as his father did, instead commanding them to take up his bones only when they are redeemed from Egypt? And why is it specifically Yosef who tells the brothers about the future redemption, rather than Yaakov? These questions will serve as the basis for this shiur.

When Does the Exile Begin?

A further question that arises in the wake of Yosef's speech is why he feels the need to tell his brothers that "God will surely remember you and bring you up from this land." Are they not currently free to get up and leave? Are they already subjugated now, during Yosef's lifetime?

This question is further reinforced by the fact that when Bnei Yisrael want to go and bury Yaakov, they need to first seek Paro's approval. Yosef, the second-to-the-king, must ask permission from the king to go and bury his own father! Moreover, he does not dare to present his request directly; he appeals via "Paro's house":

And Yosef spoke with Paro's house, saying: If I have found favor in your eyes, please speak to Paro, saying….

Paro indeed agrees immediately, but the manner of the request is most surprising. We have the sense that Yosef's position is not as high and mighty as we had imagined. In a certain sense, he is subjugated, enslaved to Paro.

In addition, when Yaakov's funeral procession sets off, the Torah tells us: "They left their children, their flocks and cattle in the land of Goshen." This verse is strongly reminiscent of the interactions between Moshe and Paro several generations later:

And Moshe and Aharon were brought back to Paro, and he said to them: Go, serve the Lord your God. Who exactly is going?

And Moshe said: We shall go with our youth and with our elderly; with our sons and with our daughters, with our flocks and our cattle we shall go, for we have a festival unto God.

And he said to them: Would that God then be with you, when I let you go, and your children; behold, for evil awaits you.

Not so; let the men then go and serve the Lord, for that is what you ask. And he banished them from before Paro. (Shemot 10:8-11)

This theme returns in the context of the plague of darkness:

And Paro called to Moshe and he said: Go, worship the Lord. Let only your flocks and your cattle remain; let your children, too, go with you. (10:24)

When Bnei Yisrael are subjugated in Egypt, Paro does not allow them to leave with their children and with their flocks and cattle. So long as they leave their children and their livestock behind, they will still have a connection with Egypt and will have to return there.

When Yaakov's sons go to bury him in Eretz Kena'an, they leave their children behind, along with their animals. These are the anchor ensuring their return – and indeed, the sons return to Egypt.

In light of the above, we might sense that the Egyptian exile has already begun, and perhaps Bnei Yisrael are already being subjugated. However, there is an important difference that should be noted between the episodes. In Sefer Shemot, Paro insists that only the men will go, while Moshe insists that everyone must go. In contrast, in parashat Vayechi, the brothers leave their children and their livestock in Egypt voluntarily. No one tells them to do so. They leave them behind because Egypt is their home; they have every intention of returning there. This is not real subjugation, but it represents the beginning of the Egyptian exile, for they have become so entrenched in Egypt that they cannot imagine leaving.

Yosef sees this reality – the way in which Bnei Yisrael are "taking root" in Egypt – and he senses that this is the beginning of a long-term exile. Yosef is the "dreamer of dreams." Although this earned him much scorn from his brothers, this quality is of profound significance. Yosef is a man of vision. He has the ability to read the present and to sense the future.[5][5]

He sees, now, how the family is settling down in Egypt (and perhaps also senses the attitude of the Egyptians towards the foreigners in their midst) and he feels that this situation is not going to solve itself easily. Already now, he discerns the early signs of exile and subjugation.

The Promise of Redemption – "God Will Surely Remember You"

In perceiving the situation and its significance, Yosef understands that Divine intervention will be needed to bring this exile to its conclusion, and therefore he tells his brothers, "God will surely remember you."

Yosef anticipates the exile, but even before it begins he foresees the future redemption, and before his death he leaves the nation with this vision.

However, it is not Yosef who "invents" the vision of exile and the redemption from it. It is Yaakov who discovers this secret, expressing it in the words, "God will be with you, and will restore you to the land of your forefathers" (48:21). Yaakov had received this prophecy several years previously, on his journey down to Egypt to see his long-lost son Yosef:

God said to Yisrael, in a night vision, and He said: Yaakov, Yaakov. And he said: Here I am.

And He said: I am the Almighty, the God of your father. Do not be afraid of going down to Egypt, for I shall make you into a great nation there.

I shall go down with you to Egypt, and I shall surely also bring you up,[6][6] and Yosef will put his hand upon your eyes." (46:2-4)

Prior to his death, Yaakov conveys to Yosef the promise of redemption, and it is Yosef who will transmit it further, to his brothers.

We shall now skip over all the years of Egyptian slavery, arriving at the beginning of the process of redemption. When Moshe is sent to Bnei Yisrael, he is commanded to give them the following message:

Go, gather the elders of Israel, and say to them: The Lord God of your forefathers appeared to me – the God of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov – saying: I have surely remembered (pakod pakadeti) you, and that which is done to you in Egypt. (Shemot 3:16)

God tells Moshe that when he tells this to the elders of Israel, they will listen to him. (Indeed, we read in verse 18: "They shall listen to you"). Why will they listen to him? The midrash (Tanchuma [Buber] parashat Shemot, siman 21) explains:

He [Moshe] said to them [the elders]: Thus said the Holy One, blessed be He: I have surely remembered you.

Bnei Yisrael had a sign: any redeemer that would come with this sign – "pakod pakadeti" – would be known to them as a true redeemer, for thus Yosef had told them: "God will surely remember you" (Bereishit 50:24). Since he mentioned the words "pakod pakadeti," immediately "the people believed" (Shemot 4:31).[7][7]

The expression "pakod pakadeti," which Moshe uses in order to convince the elders of Israel to listen to him, is the same language that was used by Yosef when speaking to his brothers. It was Yosef who had planted in the hearts of Bnei Yisrael the hope of redemption, by telling them twice "pakod yifkod."

This hope, originally inspired by Yosef, had echoed in the ears of Bnei Yisrael subjugated in Egypt. Yosef's words had been passed from the mouth of one suffering slave to the ear of another; from father to son, throughout the years of crushing slavery, maintaining the hope that one day they would be redeemed.

But Yaakov himself had foreseen the redemption. Why, then, did Yaakov not tell his sons himself? Why did he choose to leave the momentous role of promising an eventual redemption specifically to Yosef?

It is possible that Yaakov passed away at a time when Bnei Yisrael were still not so entrenched in Egypt, and therefore it was not yet appropriate to prophesize about a redemption from there. Therefore, he revealed this only to Yosef, and when Yosef was about to die he decided that the time was right to make the matter known.

However, it is possible that there was also a deeper reason; that it was specifically Yosef's words that would have to accompany Bnei Yisrael over the course of the long and difficult Egyptian exile. It was specifically Yosef's words that echoed in their ears all this time, and specifically his words that came to represent redemption.

"You Shall Take Up My Bones"

Furthermore, Yosef is not buried in Eretz Kena'an, as Yaakov was. Rather, his bones are kept in a casket in Egypt. It seems that this is no coincidence. Yosef could have commanded his brothers to bury him in the land of Israel – as Yaakov had commanded his sons. And had there been any concern that Paro would not agree to this, he could have arranged it with Paro in advance. However, Yosef chooses to command his brothers to take up his bones together with them when they leave Egypt, at the time of their redemption.

Indeed, when Bnei Yisrael leave Egypt, the Torah emphasizes the fact that Moshe fulfills Yosef's last will, and takes his bones:

And Moshe took the bones of Yosef with him, for he had made Bnei Yisrael swear, saying: God will surely remember you, and you shall take up my bones from here with you. (Shemot 13:19)

The Torah says nothing about the bones of the other brothers, although it would seem reasonable to assume that they, too, were brought up from Egypt. The Torah records only Yosef's command, and the fact that Bnei Yisrael fulfill his wish. Apparently, then, the taking up of Yosef's bones is a matter of great importance. Why is this so?

When Yosef commands his brothers to take up his bones, he binds this together with the matter of redemption: "God will surely remember you, and you shall take up my bones with you from here."

The taking up of Yosef's bones, then, is closely bound up with the redemption, as the midrash explains:

The time for Israel's redemption arrived… and Moshe walked about the city for three days and three nights to find Yosef's casket, for they could not leave Egypt without Yosef. Why? For so he had made them swear, prior to his death, as it is written (Bereishit 50), "Yosef made Bnei Yisrael swear, saying…."

When he [Moshe] had become extremely weary, he was met by a certain Segula[8][8] met him… She said to him, Come with me and I will show you where he is. She led him to a stream, and said: In this place the magicians and wizards made a casket of 500 talents, and cast it into the stream. And so they said to Paro: Do you want this nation never to leave here? Here are the bones of Yosef. If they never find them, they will not be able to leave.

Right away Moshe stood at the edge of the stream and said: Yosef, Yosef! You know how you promised to Israel (Bereishit 50), "God will surely remember you!" Give honor to the God of Israel, and do not hold back the redemption of Israel!... Ask for mercy from your Creator and rise up from the depths. Immediately, Yosef's casket began to rise up from the depths, like a single reed. Moshe took it and placed it upon his shoulder…." (Devarim Rabba 11:7)

Yosef's bones continue to accompany Bnei Yisrael on their journeys through the desert[9][9], and afterwards during the years of conquest and division of the land. Only after the process of redemption is complete, after the death of Yehoshua, do we find a description of the burial of Yosef:

And the bones of Yosef, which Bnei Yisrael had brought up from Egypt, they buried in Shekhem, in the portion of the field which Yaakov had purchased from the sons of Chamor, the father of Shekhem, for a hundred 'kesita,'[10][10] and they became an inheritance for the children of Yosef. (Yehoshua 24:32)

Yosef is not buried in Eretz Kena'an immediately after he dies. Rather, his bones remain with Bnei Yisrael in exile, and they accompany Bnei Yisrael throughout the process of redemption. What is the significance of this?

Repair For The Sale of Yosef

This may be viewed as a repair ("tikkun") for the sale of Yosef. Yosef had been sold by his brothers in Shekhem, and that is the beginning of the story of the Egyptian exile. The redemption from Egypt is bound up with a repair for the sin of selling Yosef, and therefore it also involves the return of Yosef (or at least his bones), specifically by the brothers,[11][11] and specifically to Shekhem, from where he was sold, as described in the midrash:

So said the Holy One, blessed be He, to the tribes: You sold Yosef; now restore his bones to their place.

A different interpretation: Yosef said to them – I swear to you that from the place from which you kidnapped me, to there you shall return me. And so Bnei Yisrael did: "And the bones of Yosef, which Bnei Yisrael had brought up from Egypt, they buried in Shekhem."[12][12] (Bereishit Rabba {Theodore-Albeck ed.} parasha 85, s.v. Va-yered Yehuda)[13][13]

According to this understanding, the Egyptian exile was a result of (or punishment for) the sale of Yosef.

However, Avraham had received a prophecy concerning this exile, in the "covenant between the parts" (Bereishit 15). It seems, then, that the sale of Yosef was merely a means by which to bring about the descent of Bnei Yisrael to Egypt.

Yosef and the Process of Exile and Redemption

Let us now consider a deeper significance to the fact that Yosef accompanies the process of redemption from Egypt.

Yosef arrives in Egypt ahead of his brothers, and he unwittingly prepares the ground for their move. It is thereby he who causes them to come down to Egypt and who facilitates their settling there. It is he who gives them the land of Goshen and ensures that they will stay there instead of going back to Eretz Kena'an!

By the same token, it is Yosef who initiates the process of redemption: when he feels that Bnei Yisrael are putting down roots in Egypt, even before their subjugation, he prophesizes "pakod yifkod," and commands them to take his bones with them when they are eventually redeemed. Thus, he paves the way for their redemption.

Sefer Bereishit does not end with the descent to Egypt and the settling there that represents the beginning of the exile. Rather, it ends with the story of two burials, which express the hope for redemption. One story is the procession of Bnei Yisrael to Eretz Kena'an, to bury their father Yaakov. The burial of Yaakov in the land of Israel concludes the stories of the patriarchs, all of whom were buried in the land of Israel.

The burial of the patriarchs in the land of Israel represents a powerful and significant hold on Eretz Kena'an by Bnei Yisrael. While Yaakov dies in Egypt, he insists that his children bury him in Kena'an, thereby continuing their powerful connection with the land, the land of their forefathers, the place where their forefathers are buried.

The second story is about the burial of Yosef. We do not read the end of this story here, only its beginning. Yosef does want to be buried in the land, but he asks not to be buried there now; rather, he will remain with Bnei Yisrael in Egypt, and his will that his bones be buried in Kena'an represents part of the hope for redemption. When they are redeemed, they will fulfill Yosef's command and take his bones up for burial in the land.

The burial of Yaakov in the land of Israel, and the oath to bury Yosef in the land in the future, together represent a heavy anchor that draws them back to the land, with the promise that redemption will arrive and take them back.

Let us now return to Yosef. Yosef is the one who initiates the process of the descent to Egypt, and he is the one who initiates the process of their redemption from there. There seems to be special significance to the fact that it is Yosef who accompanies Bnei Yisrael in the processes of exile and redemption (through his bones and his prophetic words). It is Yosef's essence that must accompany the nation through these formative experiences. Why is this so? What is Yosef's special essence?

Ascent Out of Difficulty

Yosef has two principal characteristics, and both are of great importance for the existence of Am Yisrael in exile as well as in preparation for their redemption.

Firstly, as we saw in parashat Vayeshev, Yosef has a special ability to deal with difficult situations; he manages to emerge from them strengthened. He is sold as a slave to Egypt, but immediately succeeds in attaining a respected position in Potifar's house. He is then cast into jail, but manages once again to achieve recognition of his special qualities, and he is once again promoted to an important position. He is then taken from the prison to become second to the king.

The ability to deal with difficult situations and to rise from those depths to even greater heights, is an ability of great importance for Am Yisrael in order, not only to survive in exile, but to emerge from exile strengthened and with greater powers.[14][14]

Maintaining Identity

Another characteristic of Yosef, which finds expression in his individual approach to his own personal exile in Egypt, is his ability to maintain his identity.

Yosef lives for many years among the Egyptians, but he never denies or hides his origins, nor is he ashamed of his heritage. Therefore everyone knows that he is a Hebrew. Potifar's wife refers to him thus:

See, he has brought us a Hebrew man, to make a mockery of us…

The Hebrew slave, whom you brought to us to make a mockery of us, came to me. (Bereishit 39:14, 17)

Similarly, the royal butler mentions him to Paro as follows:

There was with us a Hebrew lad, a slave to the officer of the guard… (41:12)

Even when he becomes second to Paro, Yosef continues to maintain his Hebrew identity:

They placed [bread] for him [Yosef] separately, and for them [the brothers] separately, and the Egyptians eating with him – separately, for the Egyptians could not eat bread with the Hebrews, for it was an abomination for the Egyptians." (Bereishit 43:32)

Despite the fact that his stubborn maintenance of his identity as a Hebrew creates a distance between him and the Egyptians, he does not capitulate.

Yosef's preservation of his Hebrew identity finds expression not only in the title "Hebrew" (ivri), but also in the fact that he always takes care to mention that God helps him.

The episode of Potifar's wife proves that Yosef does not succumb to Egyptian culture; rather, he continues to maintain the moral standards that he learned in his father's house. As the midrash teaches:

Rabbi Pinchas said: Yosef was imbued with the Divine spirit, and a spirit of wisdom, from his youth until the day he died. It guided him in every matter of wisdom like a shepherd guiding his sheep. And despite all his wisdom he was inclined after a woman, but when he sought to engage in sin, he saw the image of his father – and withdrew and conquered his inclination. (Pirkei de-Rabbi Eliezer, 38)

When Bnei Yisrael were mired in the Egyptian exile, they needed Yosef's image to accompany them so that they would be able to get through the experience intact, and to remain worthy of redemption from their exile, and to be able to emerge strengthened.

The image of Yosef – who himself lived in exile for many years, and grappled with it – is the image that Bnei Yisrael keep in mind as they deal with their own exile experience.[15][15]

Yosef, who had experienced difficult situations and had emerged from them successfully, prepares Bnei Yisrael for their exile and prophesizes that they will emerge from it; that there will be a redemption.

Yosef, who took care throughout his life to acknowledge God's help, is the one to remind Bnei Yisrael that God will redeem them and save them from their troubles.

Yosef, who maintained his Hebrew identity even when in the midst of the Egyptians, is the one who Bnei Yisrael keep in mind during their difficult experiences in exile, when they are almost assimilated among the Egyptians and submerged in the 49^th level of impurity. They still manage to preserve their identity, and in this merit they are redeemed. As the midrash teaches:

There were three good attributes in Bnei Yisrael's favor in Egypt, and in their merit they were redeemed: They did not change their names, nor did they change their language, and they refrained from licentiousness. (Bamidbar Rabba, 13)

Translated by Kaeren Fish